Guide · Modernization
SAN, NAS or hyperconverged: choosing datacenter storage
How block, file and hyperconverged storage differ, which workloads each suits, and the questions to answer before a storage refresh.
In short: a SAN (storage area network) provides block storage for databases and virtual machines that need high, predictable performance. A NAS (network-attached storage) provides shared file storage for documents, media and home directories. Hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI) combines compute and storage in the same servers, scaled by adding nodes, and suits virtualised estates that want simpler operations. Many datacenters use more than one, chosen workload by workload.
Block, file and object storage
- Block (SAN): volumes presented to servers as if they were local disks. Best for databases and virtual-machine datastores.
- File (NAS): folders shared over the network. Best for documents, shared drives and media.
- Object: data stored as objects with metadata, accessed over HTTP. Best for backups, archives, large unstructured data and AI datasets.
When does hyperconverged fit?
HCI suits organisations running mostly virtualised workloads that want to scale in predictable steps and manage compute and storage from one console. It is less suited to workloads where storage needs grow much faster than compute, or to very large single databases with specialised performance needs, where a dedicated SAN may be better.
Questions to answer before a storage refresh
- Which applications use the storage, and what performance (IOPS, latency, throughput) does each need?
- How fast is capacity growing, and for which data?
- What are the recovery point and recovery time objectives for each workload?
- Does any data have residency or retention rules?
- How will data be migrated from the old system, and in what windows?
- Who will run the new platform, and what skills do they have?
Protection is part of the design
Snapshots, replication to a second site and backups with an immutable copy should be designed with the storage, not added later. See backup and disaster recovery: RPO, RTO and the 3-2-1 rule.
Experience at scale
Nuclear Edge delivered storage SITC at the Shastri Park datacenter site under a MeitY and DMRC engagement and datacenter modernisation for DRDO with PwC covering HPE infrastructure and workload balancing. See datacenter modernisation and storage.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between SAN and NAS?
A SAN provides block-level storage that servers use like local disks, suited to databases and virtual machines. A NAS provides file-level shared storage over the network, suited to documents and shared drives.
What is hyperconverged infrastructure?
HCI combines compute, storage and virtualisation in standard servers managed as one system, scaled by adding nodes, instead of separate servers and storage arrays.
Is hyperconverged better than SAN?
Neither is better in general. HCI simplifies operations for virtualised workloads; a SAN can suit large databases or estates where storage grows much faster than compute.