Guide · Energy & Power
AIS vs GIS substations: differences, cost and when to choose each
Air-insulated and gas-insulated substations do the same job in very different footprints. How land, environment, cost and maintenance decide between them.
In short: an air-insulated substation (AIS) uses open air as insulation between conductors and equipment, so it needs a large site but is cheaper to build and easy to inspect. A gas-insulated substation (GIS) encloses switchgear in earthed metal compartments filled with SF6 gas, taking a small fraction of the land, which suits cities, mountains, industrial plants and polluted or coastal sites. GIS costs more to build; the land saved, reliability and lower maintenance often make up the difference.
How do AIS and GIS differ?
| AIS | GIS | |
|---|---|---|
| Insulation | Air, by spacing | SF6 gas in sealed enclosures |
| Footprint | Large | Much smaller |
| Capital cost | Lower | Higher |
| Exposure to weather and pollution | High | Low |
| Maintenance | More frequent, easy access | Less frequent, specialised |
| Installation | Outdoor erection over a wide area | Indoor or compact bays; clean-room style assembly |
| Special handling | None | SF6 gas handling, leak monitoring and recovery |
Where GIS is the better choice
- Cities: land is scarce and expensive; GIS fits on a small plot or inside a building, as in metro and urban distribution substations.
- Mountains: narrow sites, snow and altitude favour compact, enclosed equipment.
- Industrial plants and refineries: limited space inside the boundary, and polluted air that would foul open insulators.
- Coastal sites: salt contamination affects open-air insulation.
Where AIS is the better choice
Where land is available at reasonable cost, such as in many rural transmission and solar pooling substations, AIS remains the economical and flexible choice. It is easier to extend and its equipment is easy to inspect and replace. Hybrid designs, using compact gas-insulated modules within an air-insulated yard, sit between the two.
SF6: the responsibility that comes with GIS
SF6 is an excellent insulating gas and a very potent greenhouse gas. GIS operators must monitor gas density, prevent leaks, recover gas during maintenance and account for it at end of life. Alternatives to SF6 are emerging at some voltage levels.
Our experience with both
Nuclear Edge has erected, tested and commissioned both types from 66 kV to 765 kV. GIS work includes 400/220 kV substations at Gumma and Wangtoo in Himachal Pradesh for HPPCL, 400/220 kV at Amargarh in Jammu & Kashmir and Sohna Road, Gurugram, for Sterlite, a 400 kV GIS at Bhachunda for GPPTCL, a 220/132 kV GIS at BPCL's Kochi refinery, a 220/33 kV GIS at AIIMS for DTL, and 66/11 kV GIS substations for Tata Power-DDL. AIS work includes the 400 kV HVDC Champa substation, the 400 kV substation at Jaypee Nigrie and the 765/400 kV Khetri substation. See substations (AIS & GIS) and the project register.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between AIS and GIS?
AIS uses air as insulation and needs a large open site; GIS encloses equipment in metal compartments filled with SF6 gas and needs much less space.
Is GIS more expensive than AIS?
GIS usually costs more to build, but it saves land and needs less maintenance, so it can be cheaper over the substation's life where land is expensive or the environment is harsh.
Why are GIS substations used in cities?
Because they fit on small plots or inside buildings, are enclosed for safety and are less affected by pollution, which suits dense urban areas and metro systems.
What is SF6 in a GIS substation?
Sulphur hexafluoride, an insulating gas that fills the GIS enclosures. It is very effective but a potent greenhouse gas, so leaks are monitored and gas is recovered during maintenance.